7 Best Bagels in Brooklyn Every Local Should Know

If you are unfamiliar with the renowned bagels of New York, our guide to the greatest bagels in Brooklyn is probably one of the most important resources you need! One of Brooklyn’s most recognizable dishes and one of the city’s most distinctive delicacies is bagels.

This guide is for you in case you haven’t had any bagels in Brooklyn yet or if you have but didn’t think your experience was the greatest possible.

Before we get started, let’s first discuss what makes the best bagels in New York City unique. Below is a list of several best bagels you can find in Brooklyn.

No other bagels are like an NYC bagel, as you may or may not know. But, once you leave New York, you won’t find anything like this excellent cuisine item created here.

There has long been a misconception that the city’s renowned water is what gives these bagels their unique flavor and superior quality. You might be wondering, “What do you mean by water? It’s just water,” but the fact that the water in New York City comes from Upstate New York and is recognized as some of the best drinking water in the world. So, it’s probably the reason why it makes the bagels so good.

According to others, this has been proven false, and the only reason New York has the greatest bagels is that the city does things better overall.

In my opinion, the two essential elements for preparing delicious NYC-style bagels are slow fermentation and dipping the bagels in boiling water before baking. This basically means that bagels of this quality may be found anywhere!

But they don’t; you can only find these delightful bagels here, and we’ll discuss which Brooklyn locations have the greatest bagels below.

1. BAGEL PUB

Although the everything bagel is one of our favorites, there is much more to Bagel Tour than that, including their incredible cold brew coffee!

The sausage and cheese bagel sandwich is my favorite here, but the ABC sandwich appears to be popular with customers. This consists of avocado, bacon, cheddar, and egg. To top it all off, pick your favorite bagel. Additionally, it’s a great place to get lox, which is very well-liked by New Yorkers.

They provide a large selection of freshly made on-site bagels, along with more than ten different cream cheese spreads. The crew here puts in a lot of effort, and now we just feel like this bagel shop is a regular stop for us.

Customers can select from a menu full of must-have coffee drinks, smoothies, and delicious baked goods.

If you want to catch up with friends or just get out and explore from your apartment, this cafe is a great place to do it. So, you must visit Bagel Pub to sample some of the best bagels in Brooklyn!

There are currently three locations: one in Crown Heights, one in Sunset Park, two in Park Slope, one-off 5th Avenue on 9th Street, and one on 7th Avenue.

2. SHELSKY’S OF BROOKLYN

Shelsky’s of Brooklyn is up next. Peter Shelsky and Lewis Spada, two Brooklyn food experts, founded Shelsky’s in 2011.

The Kosher bagels, bagel sandwiches, and unquestionably the lox and smoked salmon are what make this shop most well-known.

Therefore, if you enjoy seafood and bagels, this location has some of the best bagels in Brooklyn. If lox isn’t your thing, you may try various cream cheese and bagel flavors. We adore the bagel sandwiches and heartily suggest trying the chili chip cream cheese!

Remember that compared to some other bagels in Brooklyn, their bagels are a little on the smaller side.

There are two Shelsky’s locations, the first of which is Shelsky’s of Brooklyn Appetizing & Delicatessen in Cobble Hill. Here, you may get fish by the quarter, half, or filet, as well as mouthwatering pastrami, corned beef, and a selection of appetizers.

The second branch of Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels is in Park Slope, and it serves breakfast sandwiches, lunch sandwiches, and fresh New York bagels with a choice of flavorful cream cheeses.

So give Shelsky’s a try if you’re ever in the mood for some of Brooklyn’s tastiest bagels!

3. GREENBERG’S BAGELS

The Holy heavenly bagels! The hot and fresh bagels that Greenberg’s on Bedford Ave in Bed Stuy produces every day are not to be missed. If you’re looking for a traditional bagel with flavored cream cheese or one of their delicious hot bagel sandwiches, this is undoubtedly one of the best bagels in Brooklyn.

The S.E.C.—sausage, egg, and cheese on everything with Mike’s Hot Honey—is my go-to.

Both delivery and pick-up are available. Just be aware that you’ll need to order using your phone and pay attention to the window where your order is being prepared. On my first visit, my bagel sat for a while because I wasn’t sure what to do.

4. BAGELSMITH

People will attest to the fact that Bagelsmith, with its two locations in Williamsburg, is known as having the “Best Bagels in Town.” Another fantastic restaurant offering some of the tastiest bagels in Brooklyn is Bagelsmith.

The fact that this bagel shop is open every day of the week sets it apart from the competition. You read that correctly—24 hours! So you can depend on Bagelsmith whenever you have an early flight or are working the night shift. This is fantastic, considering the majority of the places on our list of the finest bagels in Brooklyn close in the afternoon or stop serving their breakfast items after a certain hour.

This store offers more than you can expect from a deli and bagel shop. Bagelsmith offers a wide variety of items, such as plain bagels, sandwiches, breakfast, muffins, salads, vegan options, and a range of coffee drinks and other beverages.

The egg and cheese or in either one of their specialties, like smoked fish, is frequently chosen by customers.

Bagelsmith makes some of the best bagels in the entire city, not just Brooklyn.

5. SMITH ST. BAGELS

This bagel shop, which boasts some of the best bagels in Brooklyn, has been serving customers tasty bagels made in-house since 2008. And there’s just no stopping!

Our preferred types of stores include fresh bagels and cream cheeses that are prepared daily in-store.

We simply can’t keep up with all of the menu options Smith St Bagels offers in addition to their wide selection of bagels. In addition to fantastic omelets and sandwiches for breakfast, they also offer burgers, wraps, salads, and more.

Try some of the interesting flavors of cream cheese, such as apple spice!

The variety of gluten-free products, the delicious baked items, the juices, and the abundance of espresso beverages are some of its best attributes.

Customers adore this place because of its dependability. Smith St Bagels is known for providing excellent bagels and helpful service.

Additionally, this is one of the few places in Brooklyn where you can find rainbow bagels!

6. LA BAGEL DELIGHT

One of the classic places in Brooklyn to get bagels is here. La Bagel Delight has earned the “Breakfast Capital of Brooklyn” title since 1986.

La Bagel Delight is the ideal rest break if you’re searching for something quick and satisfying.

Grab one of their must-have bagels or bagel sandwiches with one of their specialty cream cheeses and a cup of coffee. It seems every Brooklyn establishment serving the best bagels also serves killer cream cheese, right?

Brooklyn is home to several La Bagel Delight outlets, which makes it quite handy. La Bagel offers a wide variety of hot and cold sandwiches, but I would suggest starting with one of their timeless breakfast sandwiches and a cup of coffee.

The lox and the vegetable cream cheese are very popular among customers.

Additionally, this Brooklyn bagel shop gives customers a chance to purchase one of those rainbow bagels fit for Instagram!

Want to elevate your Instagram posts in NY? Click here.

Finally, don’t be hesitant to include one of their delicious baked products; they are simply too excellent to pass up.

7. BAGEL WORLD

Bagel World, located in Park Slope and Fort Greene, is another fantastic location for bagels in Brooklyn. Customers greatly enjoy Bagel World because they have been boiling and baking their own bagels daily since they first opened in 2003.

This is a great neighborhood restaurant with a queue usually waiting for the delicacy and a warm atmosphere. Customers adore the bagels most of all, along with the prompt and courteous service.

They provide a wide range of must-try items, such as their lox bagel sandwiches, and it’s one of the spots in Brooklyn to find rainbow bagels.

According to one Yelp reviewer, “Highly suggest this spot to get rid of Sunday scaries or simply get rid of a hangover from Saturday night.”

Looking for a place to enjoy your night? Click here.

Whether you’re looking for a quick breakfast sandwich or a vegan option, Brooklyn has you covered with its many delicious bagel shops. Bagelsmith offers traditional and creative options, while Smith St Bagels and La Bagel Delight are renowned for their rainbow bagels. Finally, don’t miss out on the tasty treats from Bagel World. In our humble opinion, Brooklyn has some of the best bagels in the entire city!